Charlie Weis was undecided as to who would start for Notre Dame in this weekend’s game against Air Force. After reviewing film and watching practice this week, he’s decided to go with Jimmy Clausen. Clausen hasn’t played in the last two games – the first a 38-0 loss to USC and the second a 46-44 triple overtime loss to Navy.

I have never been and never will be a football coach – on any level. But I am a die-hard Irish football fan and have watched each game this season. Based on what I’ve seen on television, I cannot understand this decision to start Jimmy Clausen. The greater production and efficiency of Evan Sharpley over Jimmy Clausen seems obvious to me. I have not witnessed any sustained drives with Clausen at QB. He’s given me no hope that he can stand in the pocket, make quick and good decisions, and deliver the ball on target. Sharpley, on the other hand, seems to at least know the offense and work under pressure. Anyone who watched the Navy game will agree with that assessment. Yes, Notre Dame lost, but they put up 44 points and moved the ball down the field. Sharpley also made several key plays under tremendous pressure.

Some have characterized Charlie Weis as too proud and a bit arrogant. It makes me wonder if he’s simply going with Clausen because he was such a highly touted recruit by Weis. Maybe Weis thinks Clausen will jump ship if he doesn’t get to play. Maybe the early investment in Clausen is worth it considering Notre Dame cannot possibly salvage this season, and Evan Sharpley will be a senior next year.

Whatever the reason, I hope Charlie Weis sees something in Clausen that I have yet to see this season. Apparently the success of the Irish over the next three years depends on it.